20 Best Pillow Top Mattress in 2024

One of the more popular mattress choices on the market, pillow-top mattresses features a soft-top layer that consumers love. With these soft tops, these mattresses can help alleviate pressure points and make you feel like you are sleeping in a luxurious hotel. Not all of these mattresses are extremely durable and they can often end up being expensive, so it’s important to do your research before buying one of these mattresses since it is such a big purchase. Here are a few tips and reviews to help you find the best pillow top mattress for your sleeping needs.

Top Rated Best Pillow Top Mattress in 2024

Best Pillow Top Mattress Review Buying Guide

When choosing a pillow top mattress, there are many options and criteria to take into consideration.

Hybrid Mattresses

Typically utilizing both foam and springs, a hybrid mattress is usually more durable and supportive, which can be perfect for a heavier person or anyone that wants a mattress that will last a long time. The springs are normally categorized as micro-coils, innerspring, or pocketed coils and are mixed with any type of foam. These beds tend to have a little bounce in them making them great for jumping on while a coil bed is perfect for those that have back pain.

Foam Mattresses

A popular type of bed these days, you see foam beds being sold by all types of companies like Casper, Nectar, and Tuft & Needle. With multiple foam types to choose like a neutral foam or polyurethane, these types of foam can range from firm to soft and is usually pretty supportive and responsive. Memory foam is also pretty popular allowing you to slowly sink into the mattress while it molds around your body, plus it will respond slowly when you move around. Not everyone who has a memory foam mattress is a fan with some people not liking how they feel stuck into the mattress. Proprietary foam is another type that is made from a blend that is unique to the company that creates it. They can also be hit or miss as far as comfort, but tend to feel like a blend of memory foam and polyfoam.

Latex Mattresses

Since it is pretty unique in its manufacturing process and feels, we are listing latex on its own. Made from actual sap from a rubber tree, latex mattresses actually have a spongy or bouncy feel. It also stays pretty cool since it is aerated for good airflow. Latex is pretty durable in comparison to other foams, which also makes them more expensive.

Gel Memory Foam Mattresses

Similar to memory foam, gel memory foam is cooler. Known for sleeping hot, memory foam actually absorbs body heat and then retains it all through the night. People who sleep hot and don’t like the experience sleeping on memory foam may prefer a cooler night’s sleep on a gel memory foam mattress.

Pillow Top Mattress Size

When considering the best pillow top mattress, go for the king size. It gives you a great combination of space and comfort giving you plenty of room to stretch out while also providing tons of comfort from the pillow top.

Edge Support for Pillow Top Mattresses

Edge support is referring to how well the edges of the bed hold their shape. When a bed totally compresses on its sides, you may find yourself falling off the bed. When looking for the best pillow top mattress on the market, keep an eye out for great edge support that is also soft in the center. This is often the result of the firm edge pushing you into the center of the bed where you and your partner will sleep together. With a hybrid bed, you will typically get the best edge support preventing issues with a too firm or too soft edge.

Motion Transfer

If you or your partner are a restless sleeper, you know that the constant tossing and turning all night can keep the other person up as well. If you have a mattress with good motion isolation, this will deaden any type of motion that will prevent you from even feeling when your partner gets out of bed to go to the bathroom. Typically, a foam bed will have good motion isolation and hybrid beds that use pocketed coils since they can localize support to lessen motion transfer. If you sleep next to a very active sleeper or you are just a sensitive sleeper, always pay attention to the motion isolation abilities of the mattress you buy.

Your Weight

Your body type and height will affect how soft or firm a mattress will feel since it determines the amount of pressure you are putting onto the bed’s surface. Those that are lighter will find a mattress firmer than a heavier person. It all depends on how much pressure you are putting onto the mattress, which can make you sink it into it more, so it feels softer. If you have back pain, a firm pillow top mattress is a good place to start and go from there.

Sleeping Type

Your sleeping style will definitely dictate what the best pillow top mattress is for you. Stomach and back sleep will want a firm mattress that correctly supports their shoulders, hips, and neck. A firm mattress will also keep your spine aligned providing great back health. If you are a side sleeper, you will want the mattress to put more pressure on your hips and shoulders, so you need to look for a soft mattress that relieves pressure. A firm mattress will push against a side sleeper and not accommodate your curves. If you sleep in several ways, it’s important to find a good in the middle mattress as far as firmness goes and choose based on the position you think you sleep in the most.

Hot Sleepers vs. Cold Sleepers

Always think about what temperature you prefer to sleep at when you are shopping for a mattress. If you find yourself sweating throughout the night or constantly waking up because you are too warm, you should look for mattresses that have cooling agents or great airflow. Avoid memory foam since it absorbs and retains body heat, which actually can be a plus for those that find themselves cold throughout the night.

Best Pillow Top Mattress

Signature Sleep Hybrid Coil Full Size Mattress

Offering three layers of softness and support, the Signature Sleep 13-inch queen-size mattress uses independently encased coils that provide support and even weight distribution. A luxurious foam pillow top features a layer of three-zone foam that contours to your body relieving pressure.

Selected rayon constructed from bamboo mattress ticking absorbs moisture and dries quickly helping your body to breathe. Meeting Federal flammability standards, the Signature Sleep Hybrid Coil Queen Mattress is conveniently shipped vacuum sealed and compressed.

Providing both soft lower and upper body comfort, the Signature Sleep Mattress comes with a firm center that will support your hips and lower back.

Ten-inch coils are independently encased coils contours to your body to give you even weight distribution while relieving all the pressure points in your body.

The mattress foam is made without heavy metals, lead, mercury, ozone depleters, and TCEP, PBDEs, and TDCPP flame retardants, and it is low in VOC emissions to help create healthy indoor air quality.

Pros & Cons

Zinus – Cloud Memory Foam Mattress

Features a plush, quilted cover using a special mix of foam layers to give you a luxurious and cloud-like feel. With an innovative foam layering system, the mattress contours to your body giving you a customized and pressure-relieving sleep experience.

Infused with natural charcoal and green tea, the Zinus provides a cleaner sleep using odor resisting features that fight odor-causing agents.

The foam is Certi-PUR US certified while the cover meets OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certifications making this a great mattress for you as well as the environment.

Using patented compression technology, this mattress is conveniently compressed and shipped and takes between 48 and 72 hours to fully decompress.

The Memory Foam features a soft Jacquard cover and a quilted Microfiber that combines for a luxurious sleep experience that relieves sore muscles and joints.

Pros & Cons

Serta Perfect Sleeper Elite 700 Innerspring Mattress, Queen

Using Serta’s Cool Twist Memory Foam along with the 886 Custom Support Innerspring, this mattress was created with unique features that help to solve sleep problems including proper alignment and back support and reducing tossing and turning.

The Cool Twist Memory Foam provides a balanced sleep temperature in the overall mattress design promoting airflow while also minimizing the impact of your partner’s movements with an advanced foam designed created for motion isolation.

The Serta Elite will also resist sagging with Comfort Last Construction by Serta along with the Best Edge Foam Encasement that prevents edge roll-off.

Serta’s new Balanced Support Foam and Comfort XD Foam provide a perfect mix of enhanced support and cushioning comfort.

This innerspring gives you a low coil gauge design for a firm feel in comparison to Super Pillow Top Plush and 600 Plush models. It also works with a Serta adjustable foundation.

Pros & Cons

Complete Comfort 600 Pillow Top Mattress

Providing a great night’s sleep, the Complete Comfort 600 Pillow Top mattress by Sleep Inc. is very affordable and uses the Traditional Innerspring Plus system to give you consistent support.

With the 360 Degree Foam Encasement feature, you get increased edge support along with soft inner foam for a totally comfortable pillow top design.

Made in the USA, the comfort and quality of the Complete Comfort Mattress are backed by a 10-Year Limited Warranty.

It features hundreds of innersprings that were created to provide consistent support when combined with comfort foams.

Pros & Cons

Sealy Response Essentials Mattress

Offering comfort, quality, and support the Sealy Response Essentials Tight Top Mattress is Certi-PUR-US Certified and provides full-body support at an affordable price.

This innerspring mattress offers ease of movement and comfort for that sleeping on a cloud feeling you want while using the exclusive Posturepedic Technology that delivers stable support that is reinforced where you need it the most, under the heaviest areas of your body.

This 8 ½ inch mattress is firm and uses the exclusive response Coil system providing a great balance of deep-down support and comfort for an excellent night’s sleep.

The Sealy Cushion Air Foam is created with cushioning foam that creates valleys and peak to allow for more airflow as well as softness while the durable woven fabric cover gives you additional comfort.

Pros & Cons

Classic Brands Mercer Pillow Top Hybrid Mattress

Combining the support of an innerspring mattress with the conforming response found in a gel-infused memory foam mattress, the Classic Brands Mercer Pillow-Top Cool Gel Memory Foam and Innerspring 12-Inch Mattress provides the comfort you need for a good night’s sleep.

Featuring a beautiful quilted knit cover, this mattress also comes with coordinating knit side panels and corded edge to give you better breathability. This is a high-quality mattress that provides a great value and will last you for many years.

With several layers of foam and a support layer of individually wrapped coils, the mattress can precisely contour to your body reducing the sensation of movement so you can sleep undisturbed.

Dispersing heat, the gel-infused memory foam produces a very comfortable layer as a sleeping surface that also provides orthopedic support for a deeper and more restful night’s sleep.
Naturally resistant to allergens and hypoallergenic, this mattress will fight all dust mites, bacteria, mold, and allergens.

This is a CertiPUR-US certified mattress that meets all program standards for durability, performance, and emissions while featuring the newest in bedding technology.
With a ten-year warranty, this mattress comes with a 100-night risk-free trial and arrives compressed for easy setup.

Pros & Cons

Serta Perfect Sleeper Select Super 500 Innerspring Mattress

Created with unique features, the 500 Super Pillow Top mattress is designed to help reduce common sleep problems including tossing and turning, correct back support, and a cool sleep temperature

With the Cool Twist Memory Foam, you get a cooler night’s sleep while the new 739 Custom Support Innerspring improves the overall mattress design to provide better airflow. The impact is minimized from your partner’s movement with the advanced foam and premium support system designs.

With the Best Edge Foam Encasement and Comfort Last Construction, you get a mattress that resists edge roll-off and sagging.
Serta’s Comfort XD Foam provides an extra soft layer that is deep and supportive gently cradling your body.

Compatible with Serta adjustable foundations, this mattress has a high coil gauge innerspring design that provides a plush feel.

Pros & Cons

Classic Brands Serena Pillow Top Innerspring King Mattress

Made with tempered steel coils that increase the longevity and durability of the mattress, this Classic Brands Serena Pillow Top Innerspring 10-Inch Mattress provides the support you need to have undisturbed sleep for many years.

This affordable mattress comes with individually wrapped coils that are wrapped in separate pockets allowing them to precisely contour to your body while reducing the feeling of movement from your partner.

Two cushioning fiber layers are used on the top and under the coils to provide a buffer layer, so you won’t ever feel the coils.

The coils are wrapped in a fabric created to lessen friction while increasing support, plus they give you consistent support distribution throughout the mattress while lessening the motion transfer between sleep partners.

Each coil moves independently and is encased in a separate pocket allowing it to work with the other coils to precisely contour each person and provide comforting pressure relief.

Pros & Cons

Classic Brands Cool Gel 1.0 Ultimate Gel Memory Foam Twin Mattress

With a luxurious cloud-like experience, the Classic Brands Cool Gel Ultimate Gel Memory Foam Mattress uses the newest in gel memory foam technology with a plusher and more comfortable sleeping surface. Made with the highest quality materials, it is affordable and comes with a BONUS plush shredded memory foam pillow.

Designed for support and comfort, the Classic Brands Cool Gel Mattress comes with a two-inch top layer made of cool gel memory foam that is ventilated and breathable providing faster recovery and conforming to your shape faster than a conventional memory foam mattress while the second layer is a comfortable support layer. The eight-inch base layer gives you the effectiveness and strength to give you the relaxation you want for the best sleeping experience.

Supporting every part of your body individually and evenly, the gel memory foam will automatically and slowly adjust to your body temperature and weight while providing total and luxurious stress-free support. Reshaping after you move, the memory foam will gently fill in any area to cradle every part of your body.

This is an adjustable base friendly mattress that does not work as well with a traditional bed frame and is durable and flexible enough to maintain its integrity and support after bending to fit into the adjustable base.

This CertiPUR-us certified mattresses meeting the program’s standards for durability, performance, and emissions.

Providing essential comfort and support, the Classic Brands Cool Gel Mattress uses premium pressure-relieving memory foam along with high-density gel foam that is aerated together providing a great night’s sleep

It comes equipped with a beautifully detailed and tailored stretch knit fabric cover that includes a waterfall edge along with matching knit side panels. Providing a comfortable and plush sleeping surface, the gel-infused ventilated memory foam along with the base is made of high-density foam that will conform to your body while relieving pressure giving you unsurpassed support all night long.

Pros & Cons

Sweetnight King Mattress in a Box Hybrid Mattress

The Sweetnight King Mattress features a breathable quilted knit pillow top cover along with bright Gray side panels.This is the perfect king mattress design that uses a gel memory foam layer that will adjust slowly to your body weight.

Inflating after 72 hours, the Sweetnight King Mattress will retain its original plush shape.
Using AMotion isolation, you get a peaceful and undisturbed sleep thanks to its innerspring construction with individually wrapped coils and gel memory foam for maximum support.

Preventing back pain and tossing and turning, this mattress helps relieve pressure while preventing motion transfer between partners to ensure you get an undisturbed night’s sleep.
This medium-firm mattress will resist roll-off and sagging using a 3-Zone pocket spring feature that is contoured for the best support ensuring the weight of your body is evenly distributed and absorbed throughout the mattress.

Providing targeted support, you get proper alignment and back support as the gel memory Foam layer adjusts slowly to your body temperature and weight providing a buffer so you will never feel the coils.

This CertiPUR-US Certified Sweetnight King Mattress in a Box is easy to set up and comes with a ten-year warranty.

Pros & Cons

Complete Comfort 700 Pillow Top Mattress

With the Complete Comfort 700 Pillow Top mattress by Sleep Inc., you get a great night’s sleep at an awesome price.

With consistent support, the Traditional Innerspring Plus system works with 360 Degree Foam Encasement allowing for improved support on the edges while the soft inner foam gives you all over comfort through the pillow top design.

With the Gel Infused Lumbar Band, you get increased support for your lumbar area, and the comfort and quality of the Sleep Inc. Complete Comfort 700 is backed by a ten-year warranty.

Pros & Cons

Classic Brands Cool Gel 1.0 Ultimate Queen Mattress

Using the newest in gel memory foam technology, the Classic Brands Cool Gel Ultimate Mattress gives you an incredibly comfortable and plush sleeping area. Made of high-quality materials, this mattress provides a great night’s sleep at an affordable price, and you also get a bonus memory foam pillow.

Using several layers of memory foam, the Ultimate Cool Gel Mattress gives you a ventilated and breathable sleeping experience using Cool Gel memory foam that provides a fast recovery time and conforms to your shape better than a regular memory foam mattress.With the eight-inch base layer, you can maintain the effectiveness and strength of all the layers while they all work together to give you the most relaxation that you need for the best sleeping experience.

This is an adjustable base friendly mattress that doesn’t work as well with a traditional frame, but when used with an adjustable base provides additional health and lifestyle benefits. Durable and flexible, this mattress easily maintains its integrity and support even after being placed into the adjustable base.

With the high density aerated cool Gel memory foam combined with the high-quality pressure-relieving memory foam, you get the comfort and support that is essential to get a deep night’s sleep. The Ultimate Cool Gel Memory Foam Mattress also comes with a stretch knit fabric cover that is detailed and tailored beautifully with matching knit side panels and a waterfall edge.

With the Gel infused ventilated memory foam, a comfortable and plush sleeping surface is created while the base is made of high-density foam that will relieve pressure and conform to your body while also regulating your temperature giving you incredible support all night long.

Naturally hypoallergenic, this memory foam mattress is resistant to dust mites, bacteria, mold, and allergens. This medium-plus with firm support mattress is CertiPUR-US Certified and meets program standards for durability, performance, and emissions.

Pros & Cons

Mattress America Frost Hybrid Pillow Top Mattress

Design to give you affordable luxury, the Mattress America Frost Mattress uses an individually-wrapped coil system that provides enhanced edge and lumbar support, undisturbed rest, and you will never feel the movements of your partner.

This mattress is a great value with the cool and balanced temperature it maintains through the night that lets your muscles heal and breath.

Certified for a healthy night’s sleep, the Frost Mattress uses Gel technology for added support and cooler sleep and also comes with a very soft and thick cover that breath well and is durable enough to last a few years.

With the ten-inch pock coil core, you get support but won’t feel like you are sinking into the mattress.

Pros & Cons

Modway Jenna Innerspring Mattress

Featuring pocket coils that are individually wrapped, the Modway is a ten-inch Innerspring Mattress that is perfect for any sleeping style. With 8 ½ inch tall coils, the mattress comes with padding underneath the two foam layers to give you the most comfort, plus it comes with a quilted polyester tight-top surface,

Relieving pressure on your shoulders, hips, and back, the Modway Innerspring Mattress gives you an even and smooth feel every night without sinking or sagging. Reducing the pressure on your neck, shoulders, back, and hips, this mattress can contour to your body using the individually wrapped pocket coils.

It also absorbs motion and limits the amount of bounce you feel with your partner allowing you to sleep comfortably no matter what your habits or schedules are.

This high-quality queen mattress also features a fire-resistant polyester barrier, which meets the flammability standards, and it comes with a one year warranty against manufacturer defects.

The Modway is an easy to set up mattress that needs to be unboxed where you plan to set it up, and it requires 24 hours to fully expand.

Pros & Cons

Classic Brands Mercer Pillow Top Hybrid Queen Mattress

Combining the great support of a wrapped coil innerspring with gel-infused memory foam, the Classic Brands Mercer Pillow-Top Cool Gel Memory Foam gives you a deeper and more comfortable night’s sleep.

With a beautiful quilted knit cover, this mattress features coordinating knit side panels and corded edges to give you better quality and breathability. The pillow top has a cushion firm feel and is naturally antimicrobial and allergy-resistant.

You get a 0.5- inch top layer of gel-infused memory foam which will disperse body heat and create a cool sleeping surface while also retaining pressure-relieving properties like traditional memory foam. The next two layers are 0.25-inch comfort foam while the fourth later of 0.5-inch comfort foam is used as a supporting layer to provide you with the best sleeping experience. The added layer of 0.75 inches of comfort foam operates with the 8-inch support layer of individually wrapped coils to contour to your body moving independently and reducing the feeling of movement.

The Gel Memory Foam is more comfortable and breathable and comfortable than the higher density visco-elastic foam helping to regulate temperature and support each part of your body evenly.

This mattress is CertiPUR-US certified meeting the US program’s standards for durability, performance, and emissions.

Pros & Cons

Signature Sleep Hybrid Coil Queen Mattress

Offering three layers of softness and support, the Signature Sleep mattress measures 13-inches of incredible comfort.

Using independently encased coils, it provides even support and weight distribution combined with a luxurious foam pillow top that has a layer of 3-zone foam that relieves pressure while contouring your body.

The foam pillow top includes one-inch of foam to create both soft lower and upper body comfort that includes a firm center that supports your hips and lower back. Select rayon construction from bamboo absorbs moisture and dries quickly allowing your body to breathe.

With ten inches of independently encased coils, you get equal weight distribution that relieves pressure points in your body.

Meeting Federal flammability standards, this Signature Sleep mattress is shipped vacuum sealed and compressed. The mattress foam is made without TCEP, PBDEs, or TDCPP flame retardants, heavy metals, lead, and mercury, plus the foam is low in VOC emissions for better indoor air quality.

Pros & Cons

Complete Comfort 600 Pillow Top Queen Mattress

This is an affordable mattress that will give you a great night’s sleep featuring soft inner foams within the pillow top give you total comfort.

Providing consistent support with the Traditional Innerspring Plus system, Sleep Inc. comes with a 360 Degree Foam Encasement feature that provides improved edge support.

This mattress is backed by a ten-year warranty and is also available in a plus or firm model.

Pros & Cons

Ultimate Dreams Crazy Quilt Pillowtop Mattress

This is a great mattress for any sleeping style since it isn’t too soft or too firm but allows for contouring and pressure point relief.

The Tri-Zone foam core gives great support while reducing or eliminating motion transfer between two people.

It has a Certi-Pur US Certification meeting the highest quality standards and is perfect for guestrooms and RVs or to be used every night.

It takes about 72 hours for it to fully take shape.

Pros & Cons

Textrade USA Inner Spring Pillow Top Mattress in A Box

Created for a good night’s sleep, the Textrade Mattress is a luxurious innerspring that features sophisticated innerspring coil technology that provides firm but soft support. The spring pockets are filled with foam making you feel like you are sleeping on a cloud.

The 11-inch high mattress has a damask cotton pillow top for beauty and the most comfort while the premium quilted pillow top mattress includes layers of soft comfort foam and anti-microbial fibers that are healthier to sleep on as well as luxurious.

Designed to be used with a platform bed frame, this innerspring pillow-top mattress needs a centrally supported frame. It is vacuum packed and compressed for shipment
Lightweight and easy to move, you can easily move the mattress to another location without a hassle.

Features 1000 15-gauge tempered steel coils that provide body support and very little motion disturbance, plus it has a border wire around the perimeter. The plush three-inch-thick pillow top is made out of layered 20 Denier foam while a Damask quilted fabric covers the mattress.

Pros & Cons

Sertapedic 300 Innerspring Mattress

This is a firm mattress that comes with individually wrapped coils that are flexible and durable reacting separately to each part of your body.

Using a special coil gauge design, this mattress will create a firm feel over the whole mattress.
It uses a layer of Serta Comfort XD Foam that cradles your body gently for more pressure relief and comfort while at the same time, the Serta Cool Twist Gel Foam gives you breathable and improved comfort.

The Sertapedic Mattress is compatible with the Serta Adjustable foundation and measures 80 inches by 60 inches by 12.25 inches.

Pros & Cons

Final Thoughts About Buying theBest Pillow Top Mattress in 2024

The winner of the Best Pillow Top Mattress Review is the Classic Brands Cool Gel 1.0 Ultimate Mattress. Naturally hypoallergenic, this incredibly comfortable and plush mattress is affordable and comes with a bonus memory foam pillow. Using high density aerated cool Gel memory foam combined with the high-quality pressure-relieving memory foam, the 1.0 Ultimate Mattress features a stretch knit fabric cover that is detailed and tailored beautifully with matching knit side panels and a waterfall edge.

The sleeping surface is created while the base is made of high-density foam that will relieve pressure and conform to your body while also regulating your temperature giving you incredible support all night long. With little motion transfer, this well-made mattress is a great value that will hold up well over the years. The definite winner of the Best Pillow Top Mattress Review is the Classic Brands Cool Gel 1.0 Ultimate Mattress hands down.